Your voice has a chance to be heard now! scamion.com - we bring changes together.

report scam

The Natural Sapphire Company


Country United States
State New York
City New York
Address 6 E 45th St
Phone 212-869-1165
Website http://www.thenaturalsapphirecompany.com/

The Natural Sapphire Company Reviews

Most Useful Comment
  • Aug 20, 2015

About 3 months back i ordered a royal replica ring from the natural sapphire ring. It cost me $2500 with a star sapphire studded in.When i received the same i was petrified; it looked like a cheap $100 ring available in hong kongs imitation jewellery shops . I checked it out with 2 local jewellers who were very certain that it was a $200imitation stuff. And the so called natural star sapphire was no more than a cheap treated coloured corundumfurious; i made several contacts with the natural sapphire company and had to deal with their very rude sales people.

The natural sapphire company simply refused to take back the ring claiming it exceeded the 5 day evaluation periodas i was expecting baby ; my husband decided not to pursue the issue. But now as i see so many negative posts on the forum about the natural sapphire company and its fraudulent ways i feel i should have filed a complaint with california department of consumer complaintand today i read about the cio of the natural sapphire company openly admitting of image manipulation of their inventory. ((Link redacted)))the natural sapphire company should be shut down by law enforcement agencies and i have decided to move ahead with complaint filing

Mark as Useful [1 vote]
  • Aug 26, 2016

Request of my ID card and credit card copy

Yesterday night I had bought a blue sapphire online and had already paid by credit card. Today, I was request by the so-called graduate gemologist (GG) Caitlyn Perlman to provide my identity card and credit card copy. I had never required to provide such details separately by the merchant online. Even she said in the email I can hide everything except the last 4 digits of my credit card.

I felt quite suspicious and wait till the afternoon where I saw their Live chat had shown "online", which was answered by the Sri Lanka office staff where she said they are trusted company and nothing to worry. I asked again whether I still need to provide ID card and credit card, she said only credit card with my name is enough.

I felt extremely insecure of the way they responded.

I reply to Caitlyn by email just now and message them in their website to cancel my order even I had not yet received the goods. Especially after I searched and found this website with the unsatisfied customers here whom had bad experiences with this company. I am sure I need to cancel without hesitation.

Because it is still not in their office hour, I will wait till 10pm (HK time) 26.8.2016 and chat with whoever is online in the Live Chat and request them to cancel my order immediately as well as my credit card amount.

  • Aug 26, 2016

Request of my ID card and credit card copy

Yesterday night I had bought a blue sapphire online and had already paid by credit card. Today, I was request by the so-called graduate gemologist (GG) Caitlyn Perlman to provide my identity card and credit card copy. I had never required to provide such details separately by the merchant online. Even she said in the email I can hide everything except the last 4 digits of my credit card.

I felt quite suspicious and wait till the afternoon where I saw their Live chat had shown "online", which was answered by the Sri Lanka office staff where she said they are trusted company and nothing to worry. I asked again whether I still need to provide ID card and credit card, she said only credit card with my name is enough.

I felt extremely insecure of the way they responded.

I reply to Caitlyn by email just now and message them in their website to cancel my order even I had not yet received the goods. Especially after I searched and found this website with the unsatisfied customers here whom had bad experiences with this company. I am sure I need to cancel without hesitation.

Because it is still not in their office hour, I will wait till 10pm (HK time) 26.8.2016 and chat with whoever is online in the Live Chat and request them to cancel my order immediately as well as my credit card amount.

  • Aug 28, 2015

My experience with New York based e-retailer in sapphire engagement rings The Natural Sapphire company is extremely bad. Last year the company declared 15% discount about a week before Valentines Day. I purchased a heart shaped blue sapphire (about 0 .35 carat) pendent studded in white gold for $4000 for my first wedding anniversary. When it arrived it nowhere looked identical to what it was displayed on the websitewww.thenaturalsapphirecompany.com. It was a big disappointmentFurther the stone had inclusions. The craftsmanship was terrible. Overall it looked like a $20 imitation stuff.

Even worst about 3 months back I approached a local jeweller to valuate it he appraised it at $400 . I was shocked so I did get it re-appraised with two more NJ based jewellers both of them appraised it at $300 and $350. I called up The Natural Sapphire Company who offered me to buy it back at original cost provided I buy a replacement jewelery from them. They are not willing to pay back the money.Recently I goggled for The Natural sapphire Company complaints and to my chagrin found huge number of consumer complaints . Most of the complaints talk about their overpriced stones and jewelry with very bad craftsmanship and doctored images on their web site.Overall keep away from this company

  • Aug 28, 2015

The Natural sapphire Company comes up with a flimsy explanation to save itself from imminent collapse

After dozens of complaints by aggrieved buyers Evan Guttman the CIO of The Natural sapphire Company has come up with face saving but inconveniencing explanation. He has conveniently foisted off all wrong doings on someone else.

http://www.thenaturalsapphirecompany.com/Blog/postings-recently-on-s-c-a-m-sites

We extensively investigated the complaints posted by The Natural sapphire Company buyers; Here is our report

Overall the explanations posted by The natural sapphire company appear to be complete whitewash and attempt to save itself

My credit card information is not safe:

Indeed the CC info is not safe with The natural Sapphire Company; when we fired some test orders from The natural

sapphire Company web site (thenaturalsapphirecompasny.

com)we realized that its nothing more than simple form mail pushed into https socket; to give an impression that its secure. This is completely against PCI guidelines. They did this possibly to save payment gateway charges, throwing credit card information of unsuspecting buyers in open.

Off-line processing of Credit cards is phased out as its extremely insecure. Worldwide entire e-commerce transactions are done real time.(except on The natural sapphire Company)

Evan Guttman tries to give some illogical explanation as to why they are having off line credit card processing. The explanation given by him makes him admit that indeed they are processing off line transactions putting customers credit

card info at risk.

We urge all those who have alreadydone CC transaction with The natural sapphire Company to exercise caution

NSC photoshops pictures of their items:

Again Evan Guttman admits extensive use of image editing software like Adobe Photoshop; He also admits that phtoshoping is not only done to enhance looks of the sapphires but also to superimpose asterism on star sapphires . This vindicate the complaints of many buyers about the Natural Sapphire Companys unethical tactics.

Professional Photographers use image editing software to remove dust particles and clean the image ; but sending hundreds and thousands of images in bulk for enhancement http://www.thenaturalsapphirecompany.us/images/jamcracker-2.png to third party companies in Philippines is certainly dubious.

Why would anyone buy something which extensively doctored in an image to look attractive? That too color stones where in tone and color are the most significant attributes governing the purchase decision. As a buyer why one should take the pain of buying-viewing-returning and so on?

NSC sold a fake stone:

If not fake why are the stones devalued in the market. There are many buyers who have complained about significant devaluation of the stone prices when appraised independently.

Check for yourself the arbitrary manner in which Jewelry and Jewelry settings are priced by the natural sapphire company

All buyers who have already bought sapphire, sapphire engagement rings etc are urged to get there inventory re-appraised. On an average our research says they are overpriced by at least 300%. If you find it significantly devalued return it .

NSC does not have any sapphires certified by an outside companies and/or wont do this at request:

The Natural sapphire churns out certificates in bulk through software. Self certification of sapphires is strictly no no. There are many forums where in buyers have complaints that The natural sapphire company avoids sending there stones to AGS and other reputed labs for certification

See below link for forum discussion

  • Aug 26, 2015

BEWARE AND BE WARNED...DECEITFUL TACTICS, FAULTY CRAFTSMANSHIP, CHEAP INFERIOR PRODUCT NSC SHOP ELSEWHERE......

Olivia's the sales extraordinaire s professionalism in coordinating the sale was exceptional, she did and promised the world to alleviate my concerns regarding their product and the genuineness and superiority of their jewelry.

I have all of her lies and deciet in writing as we created my ring over the net and all my concerns were responded to and quashed via email.

I regret buying my stone set in a ring sold on their web site. The ring and stone ordered look completely different as that which is described in their images. My ring and so called natural stone cost $3600 AUD BIG MISTAKE.

When it arrived the value stated on the package stated $150 described as costume jewelry. When I questioned this they said this was essential "to save importing taxes and fees" ripping off the government too.

Well to make things worse I opened my ring examining it closely I noticed my sapphire looked nothing like what I ordered in colour, the actual setting was nothing like the one I ordered VERY POORLY MANUFACTURED. I ordered square I got a somewhat square oval which is out of proportions some sides more rounded then the others its quite obvious to the wearer trust me.

The four prongs which hold the stone in tact you have 3 which are visibly there and holding the stone and the fourth which is barely visible and paper thin can be bent out by had. Such a poorly put together piece of CRAP but I wear it because this is the wedding ring I choose my husband had his doubts all along but I insisted.

Worse still I had it taken t a jeweler 1 seemed to think the stone was glass, the other said a semi precious stone NOT A SAPPHIRE and definitely heat treated. The jeweler commented the workmanship and metal was out of CHINA.

I will save up and get it reset I dont want to find out any more news on the rubbish I have purchased so I will not take it to a gemologist for more disappointment. I wish this site was available before I purchased my ring, when I looked for reviews on this company prior to purchase I only found one on the BBB accredited website which rated them as A+ sooo grossly incorrect. Since them I have found the NSC flogging their jewelry on ebay I wish I had brought my ring through the NSC via ebay because ebay have a return policy which the company would have to add hear to and I would be entitled to get my money back. and buy something decent/ real elsewhere maybe a walk in store.

They haven't heard the end of me yet.

  • Aug 26, 2015

I learned my lessons the hard way. I bought from The Natural Sapphire Company and experienced embarrassment of life time; made myself to appear like a stingy idiotic boyfriendDo you want to go the same path? I bought a sapphire engagement ring for staggering $9700 in platinum; studded with pink sapphire; emulating Kate Middleton engagement ring design.Purchase date 23Rd Jan order No. 10786. from The Natural sapphire Company. Paid by Credit Card. Its photograph on the web site of Natural sapphire Company shined as if its a jewelry from heaven . A piece of exquisivity ; a marvel ; perfect to make my engagement a memorable life time moment The order was received; but just a day before my engagement; what I got was terrible piece of crap. Craftsmanship was worst then the imitation jewelry, stone looked like plastic marble I returned it; got my refund back; but hey do you want to do this? Return the engagement ring after engagement? I had a mouthful of abuses to owner of Natural Sapphire Company one Michael Arnstein who seems to be habituated to complaints and kept parroting that he will give the refund; I got the refund but lost the most memorable moment I goggled for the The Natural sapphire Company complaints and here is what I found ; (below is the compilation by some another pissed off consumer) Looks like these guys issue false Press releases and make videos for self-generated publicity 1) There are at least 700-800 complaints registered against Natural Sapphire company by aggrieved customers 2) Most of the recognized Color stone forums like pricescope.com have expelled The Natural Sapphire Company for its dodgy sales tactics 3) The Natural Sapphire company legally doesnt exist ?. It has no registration 4) Recently their fraudulent claim over the generic name The Natural sapphire Company is rejected by Trade Mark authority.. 5) The Natural Sapphire Company Owner Michael Arnstein is carrying criminal charges on him 6) Buying from The Natural Sapphire Company through Credit card is extremely risky process as their CC process is not safe 7) The sapphires which they sale is almost 500% over priced then market rate (fake sapphires overpriced double whammy ) 8) The Natural Sapphire Company is not a member of AGTA American Gem Stone Association 9) The Natural Sapphire Company and Its owner project itself deceitfully as jeweller for Royalty of UK". In reality they are just the fake replica makers of Kathy Middleton engagement sapphire ring 10)visit www:.naturalsapphirecompany?.net to get full expose on NSC.

  • Aug 25, 2015

I learned my lessons the hard way. I bought from The Natural Sapphire Company and experienced embarrassment of life time; made myself to appear like a stingy idiotic boyfriend

Do you want to go the same path?

I bought a sapphire engagement ring for staggering $9700 in platinum; studded with pink sapphire; emulating Kate Middleton engagement ring design.

Purchase date 23Rd Jan order No. 10786. from The Natural sapphire Company. Paid by Credit Card.

Its photograph on the web site of Natural sapphire Company shined as if its a jewelry from heaven .

A piece of exquisivity ; a marvel ; perfect to make my engagement a memorable life time moment

The order was received; but just a day before my engagement; what I got was terrible piece of crap. Craftsmanship was worst then the imitation jewelry, stone looked like plastic marble

I returned it; got my refund back; but hey do you want to do this? Return the engagement ring after engagement?

I had a mouthful of abuses to owner of Natural Sapphire Company one Michael Arnstein who seems to be habituated to complaints and kept parroting that he will give the refund; I got the refund but lost the most memorable moment

I goggled for the The Natural sapphire Company complaints and here is what I found ; (below is the compilation by some another pissed off consumer)

Looks like these guys issue false Press releases and make videos for self-generated publicity

1) There are at least 700-800 complaints registered against Natural Sapphire company by aggrieved customers

2) Most of the recognized Color stone forums like pricescope.com have expelled The Natural Sapphire Company for

its dodgy sales tactics

3) The Natural Sapphire company legally doesnt exist ?. It has no registration

4) Recently their fraudulent claim over the generic name The Natural sapphire Company is rejected by Trade Mark authority..

5) The Natural Sapphire Company Owner Michael Arnstein is carrying criminal charges on him

6) Buying from The Natural Sapphire Company through Credit card is extremely risky process as their CC process is not safe

7) The sapphires which they sale is almost 500% over priced then market rate (fake sapphires overpriced double whammy )

8) The Natural Sapphire Company is not a member of AGTA American Gem Stone Association

9) The Natural Sapphire Company and Its owner project itself deceitfully as jeweller for Royalty of UK". In reality they are just the fake replica makers of Kathy Middleton engagement sapphire ring

10)visit www:.naturalsapphirecompany?.net to get full expose on NSC.

  • Aug 22, 2015

Recently I bought a Pad from The Natural sapphire Company www.thenaturalsapphirecompany.com ; I had saved its images as available on there web-site before buying . When the stone arrived I was shocked to see a totally different color stone ; on close compare with photographs and the actual stone it was very clear that NSC had used lighting effects and image manipulation to enhance colours

When I approached them to return the stone they flatly refused sighting that my computer monitor may have problem and it showed a different color; which was completely untrue

On further checking on the net I found this link

http://www.pricescope.com/forum/colored-stones/unscrupulous-scandalous-status-quo-t137658.htm

As things did not work through phone I visited their showroom and what I saw over there almost got me an heart attack

There sales person while checking my order came up with the print out of my order details

The order details where in thir file (along with all other order details which they received through the e-mail) and guess what? My entire credit cart details with CVV number etc. were printed on them. THEY ARE NOT SUPPOSE TO DO THIS. When I questioned; they told me with each order they receive e-mail with all these details. Not encrypted . Further there payment

gateway is off line. (they show the web site as its online and completely secure). This company is putting everyones credit card info in open

This is shocking I dont know what to say and what to do? This is complete voilation of PCI guidelines Why the hell I even did any business with thenaturalsapphirecompany.com

I have cancelled my CC card and reported this issue to BBB where else I can report?

These guys use all sorts of unscrupulous tactics to sale there sapphire

Further I come to know that The Natural Sapphire Company which claim to have untreated sapphires and charge premium on that are actually Beryllium Treated in Lanka where they have back office

SO BE VERY VERY CAREFUL IF YOU WANT TO BUY ANYTHING FROM THE

NATURAL SAPPHIRE COMPANY

  • Aug 21, 2015

I have no reservations in saying that I am the owner of the company which is a direct competitor to The Natural Sapphire Company. We have been observing dubious ways of running business by The Natural Sapphire Company and its owner Michael Arnstein. We have also observed lot of self-generated publicity this company has created around Kate Middleton's sapphire engagement ring and so called replica of the sapphire ring

Here are some facts about the Natural Sapphire company who sell natural sapphires, natural sapphire engagement rings and sapphire jewelry including Natural rubies

a) First and the foremost their stuff is about 400% more expensive then what is offered by other companies. Under the garb of natural they sell their inventory at exorbitant price

b) Most of their inventory is self certified and they avoid giving their inventory to third party lab for certification

c) If one may observe sapphire engagement rings on The natural sapphire company web site ; are priced arbitrarily ; sometime there pricing doesnt make sense ; For example many simple solitaire rings are 200% more expensive than same metal same stone pave rings

d) Then we have observed huge number of duplicate inventory listed at different prices ; for example stones are listed in pairs as well as listed separately having totally different prices.

e) Further there are hundreds of post and negative review on the forums about The natural sapphire Company about how the company indulges in extensive image manipulation. Just Google for The Natural sapphire company complaints. And you will see hundreds of negative post on Natural Sapphire Company

f) Further we understand they had a reputed India based company managing their software development. The Natural Sapphire Company and its owner Michael Arnstein in a deep conspiracy tried poaching the employees of this company by offering them illegal pay offs, and promise of illegal immigration in USA. The conspiracy was uncovered by Indian cyber police and currently Michael Arnstein is facing criminal charges

g) We were approached by this software company who told us that Michael Arnstein further resorted to threats to the family members of the directors of this software company which is very disturbing

h) Then The Natural sapphire Company holds the dubious distinction of having a rip off site completely dedicated to them on http://www.thenaturalsapphirecompany.us

Anyone wishing to do any business with The natural sapphire Company is suggested to exercise caution

  • Aug 8, 2015

The Natural Sapphire Company is internet based operator selling sapphires, sapphire engagement rings. The Natural sapphire company also operates on ebay and Amazon through its web stores http://stores.ebay.com/The-Natural-Sapphire-Company

Most of its sapphires are self-appraised. They also self-certify the sapphires as untreated.

Many experienced gross devaluation of sapphires bought from The Natural Sapphire Company when they tried to re-sell it

Before buying it is advisable to revaluate the sapphires from 3rd party reputed appraisers also get them certified through labs like AGS or GIA at vendors cost

  • Aug 8, 2015

About 3 months back i ordered a royal replica ring from the natural sapphire ring. It cost me $2500 with a star sapphire studded in.When i received the same i was petrified; it looked like a cheap $100 ring available in hong kongs imitation jewellery shops . I checked it out with 2 local jewellers who were very certain that it was a $200imitation stuff. And the so called natural star sapphire was no more than a cheap treated coloured corundumfurious; i made several contacts with the natural sapphire company and had to deal with their very rude sales people.

The natural sapphire company simply refused to take back the ring claiming it exceeded the 5 day evaluation periodas i was expecting baby ; my husband decided not to pursue the issue. But now as i see so many negative posts on the forum about the natural sapphire company and its fraudulent ways i feel i should have filed a complaint with california department of consumer complaintand today i read about the cio of the natural sapphire company openly admitting of image manipulation of their inventory. ((Link redacted)))the natural sapphire company should be shut down by law enforcement agencies and i have decided to move ahead with complaint filing.

Write a Review about The Natural Sapphire Company